« Desert Island Double Dip: Part 1 | Main | Drunky Tuesday... »

February 07, 2006

Desert Island Double Dip: Part 2

Well, yesterday’s entry didn’t quite spark the dialogue I was hoping for. Oh well. Happens. Like the time I hosted the conference entitled, “Anyone Else Wanna Talk About Why Toad the Wet Sprocket Never Made It Really Big?” Occasionally I pick my pop culture chats badly. Alas.

For those of you tuning in, today is Disc 2 for my desert island double-CD compilation. A friend of mine thought I was debating which extant double-album I would want to have on me if in fact my plane crashed like Oceanic 815. In fact, I was making the illogical assumption that I would in fact burn two CDs worth of music and bring it on the plane on the slight chance it might crash on a deserted island. His idea makes more sense, but mine bespeaks waaaay more paranoia and fatalism. I prefer my way. (If I had to go his way though…“Quadrophenia” by The Who. That’s my current choice. Behind that, “Blonde on Blonde”, then “Exile on Main Street”, and coming in at #891 on the list, “Kajagoogoo Performs the Best of John Tesh”. I have no idea if that exists, but if it does, I suggest we subject terrorists to it. They’ll be talking faster than if Jack Bauer were in the room with them.)

Without further ado, Disc 2…

***

“Somebody Told Me”, The Killers

I keep waiting to get sick of this song, and I never do. Simply hasn’t happened. Can’t imagine it’s gonna happen anytime I’m on an island looking for coconuts and talking to volleyballs, either. Has the perfect opening riff to propel Disc 2 off the bat. Disc 1 has the long, slow, percolating intro with FatBoy Slim’s “Right Here, Right Now”, and you know how I never like to repeat myself when it comes t these compilations. Having this song with me will also give me a chance to perfect my karaoke rendition of this tune, since I bombed my initial stab at it pretty badly a few weeks back.

“Never Let Me Down Again”, Depeche Mode

Since The Killers mix the best of today’s rock with the best of old new-wave, let’s go back to new wave’s heyday and pull this track out of the ether and plop it down at Track 2. Only got into this song over the last year, and find it one of the great “headphone” songs---those tunes where close intense listening rewards one with layers upon layers of cool sounds, intricately woven and apparently only under close scrutiny. And I’ll be listening to the song a lot, so songs on this compilation have to stand up to multiple listens.

“Cells”, The Servant

Better known as “The Really Cool Song On All The ‘Sin City’ Trailers”. Dripping with atmosphere and humor in equal doses, it sounds like the coolest band that has a profile on MySpace. It sounds like something that could score a gunfight at high noon, if the gunfight took place on some distant planet, but talks about eating Chinese food on the floor and trying to beat a level in a video game. It works on every level and is unassailably cool. Because let’s face it, I’ll need all the cool boost I can get. I just crashed on a freakin’ island. There’s sand in my butt. It’s itchy. Let me have The Servant, damnit.

“La Cienega Just Smiled”, Ryan Adams

Heartbreakingly gorgeous. Some of Adams’ stuff sounds so tossed off as to be showing off how prolific he is, but this has a measured grace that shows a true artist. The fact that music this gorgeous can be created gives me great comfort. Seems like a good song to play at sunset. Or sunrise. Or, really, any time at all.

“Fake Plastic Trees”, Radiohead

Went to Providence a few weeks back to visit some friends, and one of them tossed “The Bends” onto her stereo after we’d all had a few drinks. I’d forgotten how good this album was, especially when played at ear-shattering levels of volume. I’m still in the camp that “OK Computer” is their best overall record, but this song, along with “Street Spirit”, are their two best songs, period. “Fake” does what all great Radiohead songs do: let you pour your own emotion into Thom Yorke’s emotive voice. Doesn’t matter so much that you understand what he says so much as feel what he says. Couple his performance with the build, build, build of the production and you have a song I wouldn’t want to live without.

“Black”, Pearl Jam

One of the most draining songs put to tape in the last 25 years. Still affects me as powerfully today as it did when I first heard it. Used to sing myself hoarse trying to keep up with Eddie Vedder after yet another disastrous romantic non-encounter. If you don’t get affected by the last verse, “I know someday you’ll have a beautiful life/I know you’ll be a star in somebody else’s sky/But why, why, why can’t it be mine?” then I’m not sure we’d get along, you and I.

“So Alive”, Love and Rockets

Time to build back up, before we hit a 3-pack of Morrissey tunes. Can’t have that now. I remember hearing this song back when MTV still had the “Buzz Bin”. Good thing, the Buzz Bin. Though they convinced me for six months that Jesus Jones was a good bad, so it didn’t always wield its power for good. This song takes the melancholy nature of the last two songs and adds seduction and a touch of electronica to the mix, especially with the ethereal synth that bedrocks the tune. Also, I dig any song that has the line, “Don’t know what color your eyes are, baby/But your hair is long and brown.” Since that pretty much sums up how I assign physical importance.

“Daft Punk Is Playing in My House”, LCD Overdrive

OK, I threw in Love and Rockets because I really wanted this song on here at some point. It’s the best damn disco-punk song ever, and I have my Playstation 2 to thank for allowing me to discover it. It’s one of the 20+ songs on “SSX On Tour”, and I found myself crashing my snowboarder into trees and not ever caring, since I was rocking out to this tune so much. There’s nothing wrong with the occasional vapid no-point-except-that-it’s-infectiously-fun song on a compilation, and lo, here we go. Listen to it and try not to either dance like a fool or grin like a fool. I dare ya.

“Amazing Journey/Sparks”, The Who

Another good thing about LCD Overdrive’s presence is that it allows me to segue nicely into my favorite live track by The Who. I love “Tommy” as a studio album, but it honestly pales in comparison to the way the album sounded live for the two or so years they toured with it after the album’s initial release. This track, from the “Live at Leeds” reissue, makes my jaw drop every time I hear it. Seems impossible that three blokes could create such a noise. It’s primal, it's visceral, it’s melodic, it's cathartic, it's on my mix.

“Since I’ve Been Loving You”, Led Zeppelin

Disc 2 on my compilation works a bit like a Set 2 for a jam band. Lot of short numbers in Set 1, but at this point, the band’s warmed up and can stretch it out into more interesting places and lengths. (Wow, that sounds….wrong.) I don’t know anyone else who would pick this as their favorite Zeppelin tune, but I guess that’s what makes me, me. (That and the fact that I am like, a wicked good kisser and stuff.) Page’s voice and Bonham’s drums absolutely blow me away in this. If all you know of Zeppelin comes from car commercials, time to check this one out.

“Time”, Pink Floyd

Continuing with the “7-minute songs by British bands” theme, we have this epic number from “Dark Side of the Moon”, which frankly couldn’t NOT be represented on this mix. I toyed with the idea of “Comfortably Numb”, in that I prefer the guitar solo in that tune, but it’s simply too enmeshed in the specific story that is “The Wall” to be included here. And it’s not like the guitar solo in “Time” is chump change, either. The entire song sounds so big that it echoes from Earth to Pluto and back again with the reverb. A good song with or without hallucinogens. Not that I’ve, um, compared.

“Soma”, Smashing Pumpkins

A bit clunky at times in the lyrics department (hey, it’s a Billy Corgan song, what did you expect), but so incredibly epic in the musical department that it blows away any lyrical imperfections. What I love about Smashing Pumpkins is its incredible embracing of melodrama: it’s how teenagers think, it’s how twenty-somethings think, and really, I haven’t seen any evidence that it goes away with age. It’s all well and good to construct a measured, poetic, Ivory-Merchant type response to the throes and woes of everyday life, and it’s also OK to shout from the mountaintops at the top of your lungs as if another mountain were resting upon your shoulders.

“Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight/The End”, The Beatles

The ending triptych from “Abbey Road” ends this compilation. Just feels right having The Beatles take us home on this mix. After all, they inspired more than a fair share of the music heard previously on these discs, so why not give them some props? Also, doesn’t hurt that the last song is called “The End”, which appeals to my mix-tape making geekery.

****

So there ya have it, an incredibly unscientific, probably-would-look-totally-different-in-six-months, desert island double-album compilation. Sorry to all Enya fans for my exclusion of “Orinoco Flow”. Trust me, was a hard one to leave off.

Any comments? Fan mail? Hate mail? Pictures of yourself on a deserted island? Feel free to drop them my way.

Posted by Ryan McGee at February 7, 2006 10:14 AM

Comments

I hadn't commented before because I wanted to see what surprises Disc 2 might bring. That and I was trying to come up w/my own playlist. In no particular order...:

"Wild Horses," Rolling Stones;
"Cells," The Servant (you got to it first, ya bastard);
"All These Things That I've Known," The Killers;
"Wish You Were Here," Pink Floyd;
"Sugar, We're Going Down," Fall-Out Boy;
"Someday," Flipsyde;
"the blower's daughter," Damien Rice;
"99 Luftballons," Nena;
"Folsom Prison Blues," Johnny Cash;
"Boys of Summer," The Ataris;
"Bullet with Butterfly Wings," Smashing Pumpkins;
"Kiss Me Deadly," Lita Ford;
"With or Without You," U2;
"Not About Love," Fiona Apple;
"Quiet," Rachael Yamagata;
"Georgia on My Mind," Ray Charles;
"Thunder Road (acoustic version)," Bruce Springsteen;
"Hallelujah," Rufus Wainwright;
"When Doves Cry," Prince;
"Livin' On a Prayer," Bon Jovi;
"Not a Virgin," Poe;
"Like a Rolling Stone," Bob Dylan;
"Feel Good, Inc.," Gorillaz;
"Come Pick Me Up," Ryan Adams;
"Nobody Loves You," Garbage;
"Wicked Games," Chris Isaak;
"Drag Queens & Limousines," Mary Gaulthier;
"American Pie," Don McLean;
"Damn It Feels Good to be a Gangsta," Geto Boys

Posted by: Tink at February 7, 2006 10:55 AM

It's good to know that someone else has a weird Killer's fetish as well. To hear me screaming I got soul but I'm not a soldier as I'm driving down the expressway is a mighty sight to be had. I agree with you completley about their mix of classic new wave with new punk. I can not get tired of them as well. And, I'm going to say something now that gets alot of people pissed off and I do not know why. I really do not like Pink Floyd at all. I honestly think they thought too highly of themselves, to make really honest music. So they were another one of those trippy acid bands that had the overall feel to them of, hey look at us we're a trippy acid band, look how cool we are.

Posted by: danny at February 7, 2006 11:12 AM

by the way, here is the mix that I would have:
1.Konstantine-Something Corporate
2.Darling Nikki-Prince
3.Say My Name-Destiny's Child (do not ask)
4.Ramble On-Led Zeppelin
5.Rocket Man-Elton John
6.Where Are You Going-Dave Matthews Band
7.Meet Virginia-Train
8.Cocaine Blues-Johnny Cash
9.Glycerine-Bush
10.Stan-Eminem
11.Somewhere Only We Know-Keane
12.Lithium-Nirvana
13.Lullaby-Stephen Lynch
14.Get a Haircut-George Thorogood
15.XO-Fall Out Boy
16.All these things that I've done-The Killers
17.Everything is Alright-Motion City Sountrack
18.Bohemian Rhapsody-Queen
19.First Day of My life-Bright Eyes
20.The Wind Crys Mary-Jimi Hendrix

Posted by: danny at February 7, 2006 11:25 AM

Dammit, I forgot "Glycerine" (though I prefer the acoustic version) and DMB. I'd have to pick either "Crash," "Satellite," or "Crush." In chatting w/Ryan, I also forgot James' "Laid" which is on repeat in my head. I think I'm going to need a bigger iPod.

Posted by: Tink at February 7, 2006 01:06 PM

Interesting list. I'm with you on "Fake Plastic Trees" and "Street Spirit" being the best Radiohead songs. I also have always loved PJ's "Black". (Poor Pearl Jam, their name abbreviates to PJ!) And "Time" by PF.

Some of the songs you listed I have, but am not really familiar with. I'm going to try to compile your desert disc songs into a mix, I think I have nearly all of them. Good times.

Posted by: Susan at February 7, 2006 01:45 PM

oh dammit. crash would be good. oh well. wait wait, what about grave digger off of his solo stuff.

Posted by: danny at February 7, 2006 02:16 PM

Or "Stay or Leave" from his solo album. (BTW, album's Some Devil.) I think "Gravedigger" would be a little too depressing for the whole "deserted on a desert island" scenario. Or it could be perfect. Hm. *skulks off to ponder*

Posted by: Tink at February 7, 2006 02:46 PM

yeah it could be right at that point when you just want to cut yourself with coconut. but i think if you immediatley followed it with the safety dance then you could make it through.

Posted by: danny at February 7, 2006 04:11 PM

I don't make mix tapes (at least not like you do, Ryan...), but here are the most recent songs on my iTunes. Hijinks ensue:

1. Maybe This Is What It Takes - Alex Parks;
2. No Excuses - Alice in Chains;
3. Hang On To Your Ego - Beach Boys;
4. Bei Mir Bist du Schon - Benny Goodman;
5. White Wedding - Billy Idol;
6. Parisien du Nord - Cheb Mami;
7. Laffy Taffy - D4L (I can't believe I paid for this song...);
8. Strange Relationship - Darren Hayes;
9. A Love That Will Never Grow Old - Emmylou Harris;
10. Last Call - Down the Line;
11. All My Exes Live in Texas - George Strait;
12. Might As Well Be Strangers - Keane;
13. 6'1" - Liz Phair;
14. Where'd You Go - Mighty Mighty Bosstones;
15. Feeling Good - Muse;
16. Hey Ya - Outkast;
17. Miss Jackson - Petey Pablo;
18. Love TKO - Teddy Pendergrass;
19. Disco Inferno - The Trammps;
20. The Maker Makes - Rufus Wainwright (shameless plug: If you don't have this, go buy it now. Seriously. The most stabbingly depressing-yet-awesome song since Pearl Jam's Black.);
21. Regulate - Warren G

Posted by: Jeanna at February 7, 2006 04:13 PM

Danny, no Safety Dancing without midgets. It's the law.

Jeanna, super-extra points for "Regulate." I know I've sucessfully bonded with new people when, in unison, we hear the intro and automatically all cry out, "Regulators...mount up."

Why oh why does file-sharing have to be so bad?

Posted by: Tink at February 7, 2006 05:18 PM

if non-midget dancing is outlawed then only outlaws will be non-midget dancers. sixteen in the clip and one in the hole nate dogg is about to make some bodies turn cold.

Posted by: danny at February 7, 2006 06:39 PM

Looks like you got some conversation this time so there you go. I wasn't really prepared to make a desert island disc (way too much pressure there) so I thought I would share two tangential thoughts instead.


1. You mentioned the perfect 10 song in your first entry. And I find this topic fascinating. There are just some songs that are perfect in every regard, but that doesn't mean they are the best song ever. I'm not even sure if the best song ever is even a 10. It may just be a 20 in one category and a 7 in another. Anyways...here is a real short list of some perfect 10 songs:


What Am I To You - Norah Jones
Gimme Three Steps - Lynyrd Skynyrd
Hot In Here - Nelly
Alison - Elvis Costello (a 10 among 10s)
Career Opportunities - The Clash
I Never Loved A Man The Way I Love You - Aretha
Till I Get To You - Nikka Costa
Nadine - Chuck Berry
Bluebird Wine - Emmylou Harris
Microphone Fiend - Eric B & Rakim


2. I wrote a paper in college with a thesis about how political opinions are implanted in us early by really random circumstances. I wonder if the same is true for music. I used to think that everyone could love Ride The Lightning if they were just exposed to it but it just doesn't work that way. We can certainly learn to expand our tastes but their are some barriers that we maintain and we all have different ones. For example, I am just never going to be into Keane/Coldplay/Rufus Wainwright/Elliot Smith, you know the whining music (although Grace is a near perfect album)

Now, I love to rock and I love soul music. It is always going to come back to that for me and it seems that these genres are somewhat unrepresented in the preceding lists. That's not wrong, I just wonder why we have different tastes. But on my island I would need to freaking rock out on occasion with some Hit The Lights - Metallica, some Die Die My Darling - The Misfits, and some Ace of Spades - Motorhead. And then I would need to mellow out with some Sam Cooke, and some Aretha, and some Otis Redding. And then get jazzed up again with some Parliament and/or Funkadelic. Now my brother loved Metallica so I get that from him but the soul/funk thing, I have no explanation. And that interests me.

Posted by: Nick M. at February 8, 2006 09:38 AM